Legislators in Utah, Pennsylvania, and Alabama are no longer just looking to block adult content—they want to monetize it. But as “porn taxes” and mandatory age verification (AV) go mainstream, the collateral damage includes independent game developers on Steam, creators on Patreon, and the very concept of digital privacy.
For decades, the “Adult” section of the internet existed in a sort of lawless equilibrium: self-reported age gates that everyone ignored and a “don’t ask, don’t tell” relationship with payment processors. That era is dead.
In a pincer movement of moral legislation and fiscal opportunism, U.S. states are redefining pornography not just as a “public health crisis,” but as a taxable commodity. And while the headlines focus on Pornhub, the real fallout is hitting the $200 billion gaming industry and the platforms that host its most transgressive content.
Legality of Adult Content
For decades, the legal shield for adult content was “Strict Scrutiny”—the highest legal standard, which requires laws to be “narrowly tailored” to use the “least restrictive means” possible. In June 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court fundamentally shifted the landscape in a 6-3 ruling.
The Court upheld a Texas age-verification law, downgrading the legal test to Intermediate Scrutiny. Justice Clarence Thomas, writing for the majority, argued that verifying age is merely an “incidental burden” on adults, comparable to showing an ID at a liquor store.
The Opposition’s View: Justice Elena Kagan, in a scathing dissent, warned that this “carves out a pornography exception to the First Amendment.” Critics argue that unlike a physical bar, where a bouncer glances at your ID and forgets you, digital verification creates a permanent, hackable record of your most private interests.
As of early 2026, the digital landscape for adult content has become a “checkerboard” of regulations. While the U.S. Supreme Court has cleared the path for age verification, different states and countries are using different levers: fiscal, technical, or total restriction, to control access.
Perhaps most alarming for the gaming community is the legal strategy of “Obscenity Creep.” In Utah, lawmakers have repeatedly attempted to categorize violent or sexually explicit video games under the same statutes as hard-core pornography.
Steam adult games Germany ban
If Utah’s approach is about taxing adult content and Google’s is about predicting who is behind the screen, Germany’s model is one of strict, mandatory compliance. In a move that has fundamentally altered the European gaming landscape, Valve (Steam) overhauled its storefront for German users to comply with the country’s Jugendschutzgesetz (JuSchG)—the Youth Protection Act.
Instead of verifying age, Steam has chosen to geoblock the content entirely. For German users, the “Adult Only” and “Frequent Nudity” filters have effectively been deleted from the store’s settings.
A worry that it can happen for other users from other countries and states.
The 7% Solution
In Utah, a new legislative push (highlighted by bills like SB73) proposes a 7% tax on all revenue generated from adult content created or sold within the state. This includes subscriptions, one-time purchases, and distribution fees. Pennsylvania is eyeing an even steeper 10% “sin tax.” The stated goal is philanthropic—funding youth mental health programs—but the mechanical reality is a nightmare for platforms like Steam and Patreon.
So does a highly-modded version of The Sims or an AO-rated visual novel trigger the “sin tax”? If the law treats a pixelated character the same as a live-action film, every digital storefront becomes a de facto “adult bookstore” in the eyes of the law.
Unlike a specialized adult site, Steam hosts a massive spectrum of content. If a developer in Utah releases an “Adults Only” (AO) rated visual novel, Valve (Steam’s parent company) must now navigate a labyrinth of state-specific tax filings and a $500 annual registration fee per entity. For a massive corporation, this is a rounding error; for an indie developer living on Patreon commissions, it’s a barrier to entry that could kill their studio.
The Economic Effect will be felt by developers as well: “The government is essentially taxing us out of existence,” says an independent developer from the r/gamedev community. “Between the 10% state tax, the 30% platform cut, and the costs of compliance, we’re left with nothing. This isn’t regulation; it’s prohibition by a thousand cuts.”
Why Adult Games are Different
The term “pornography” in these bills is often dangerously broad. For gamers and creators, this triggers several critical issues:
- The “AO” Stigma: Steam has historically been hesitant about AO content. If states begin taxing this content differently, Valve may simply choose to “darken” adult games in those regions rather than deal with the accounting overhead. We are already seeing this in Germany and several US states where certain games are simply “unavailable in your region.”
- The Patreon Privacy Pivot: Patreon is the lifeblood of independent adult game development. However, to comply with new laws and payment processor demands (from Visa and Mastercard), Patreon has ramped up mandatory ID verification for creators.
- The Compliance Tax: Let’s face it small developers don’t have legal teams. If they are forced to register with state “pornography databases,” many will simply stop selling to US residents or even worse stop developing all together.
-
The Digital Sin Tax: Adult Games just got more expensive
As digital ‘sin taxes’ and mandatory ID scans sweep the Western world, the landscape for adult games is changing forever.
I am an independent journalist and adult game reviewer. If you like my articles or want to advertise your games you can check out my Patreon
Your ID, Please – Porn age verification laws 2026
Beyond the tax, 25 U.S. states have moved toward mandatory age verification. To enter an adult site, you no longer click “I am 18”; you scan your face or upload your driver’s license.
The data security implications are staggering. In 2024, AU10TIX, a major identity verification firm used by X (formerly Twitter) and TikTok, left administrative credentials exposed for over a year. This meant that the very documents used to prove “safety” were ripe for the taking by identity thieves.
The LGBTQ+ Impact – The ACLU argues that these laws disproportionately harm marginalized communities. If a trans person or an LGBTQ+ youth in a restrictive state is forced to use a government ID to access health information or community forums (which often fall under “sexual material” definitions), it creates a dangerous “paper trail” of their identity.
On Reddit, the backlash is palpable. In subreddits like r/privacy and r/Steam, users aren’t just complaining about “losing their porn”; they are terrified of the “Master List.”
“I don’t care about the content. I care that a third-party company in a country I’ve never visited now has a high-res scan of my ID linked to my sexual preferences,”
IS YOUR PRIVACY WORTH THE PRICE?
The “Digital Sin Tax” is officially here, and the days of anonymous browsing are fading fast. If you’re tired of being tracked, taxed, and targeted, my latest Patreon-exclusive guide is exactly what you need.
In this Privacy Survival Guide for Gamers, I’m pulling back the curtain on how to navigate the 2026 digital landscape without leaving a paper trail.
Inside the guide, you’ll discover:
- The Untraceable Checkout: How to set up an anonymous payment for Patreon so your bank never sees your subscriptions.
- The ID Shield: My top picks for the best VPN for age-restricted sites—tested to bypass state-level “blackouts” and AI bouncers.
- Digital Ghosting: instructions on using a virtual credit card for adult content to keep your real identity off the grid.
- Which Privacy Enhanced Browser I trust to keep my privacy real.
Don’t let new laws turn your private hobbies into public records. Secure your digital freedom today.
The “Splinternet” and the Rise of the VPN
The result of these laws isn’t a decrease in consumption; it’s a spike in digital evasion. When the UK and several US states (Texas, Utah, Virginia) implemented strict AV laws, ProtonVPN and other encryption services saw triple-digit growth. In the UK, ProtonVPN briefly surpassed ChatGPT in download rankings.
Your ZIP code or IP address determines your freedom to browse
The world is currently splitting into two technical philosophies:
The American Model (Identity-Based): Show us exactly who you are so we can verify your age. is pretty straightforward. Across the pond the European Model is a bit different. The EU is currently piloting a system in Denmark, France, Greece, Italy, and Spain using Zero-Knowledge Proof (ZKP). In this setup, a government app confirms you are 18+ to the website without ever revealing your name, address, or ID number.
| Model | US State Model | EU Pilot Model |
| Verification Method | Driver’s License / Biometrics | Government Digital Wallet |
| Data Retention | Often held by 3rd party firms | Anonymous Token (ZKP) |
| Privacy Level | Low | High |
| Platform Impact | High Friction / Geo-blocking | Standardized API |
The AI “Bouncer”
While state governments are building legal walls, Google is building an invisible, AI-powered “bouncer” to police its platforms. This technology marks a shift from asking for permission to making executive decisions about who you are based on your digital footprint.
How the “AI Bouncer” Works
According to a 2025 YouTube update, Google is rolling out machine learning tools that estimate a user’s age by analyzing a variety of signals. This isn’t just about the birthday you entered when you signed up for Gmail; it’s far more granular.
- Recommendation Safeguards: Limiting repetitive views of certain content types to prevent algorithmic “rabbit holes.”
- Behavioral Signals: The AI analyzes the types of videos you search for, the categories of content you watch, and how long you’ve had your account.
- Account Indicators: For many, the “AI bouncer” may already consider you verified if you’re a YouTube Premium subscriber with a credit card on file or a creator who has previously submitted an ID for advanced features.
- The “Teen” Experience: If the AI flags you as a minor, YouTube automatically triggers extra protections:
- Disabling Personalized Advertising: Stopping the data-harvesting machine for users under 18.
- Digital Wellbeing Tools: Features like “Take a Break” and “Bedtime” reminders are enabled by default.
The End of the Digital “Wild West”
The “Digital Sin Tax” and mandatory age verification are no longer hypothetical debates—they are the new operating reality for the adult gaming industry. What began as a local effort in some states has metastasized into a global regulatory framework that treats digital intimacy with the same legal scrutiny as tobacco, firearms, and gambling.
For developers, this means the era of “upload and forget” is over. Success in 2026 and onward will require a legal team as much as an art team. For users, it means the internet is losing its borderless, anonymous nature, replaced by a “checkerboard” of access where your ZIP code or IP address determines your freedom to browse.
The Road Ahead (2026–2030)
The next four years will likely be defined by several major shifts in how we interact with adult media:
The Rise of the “Verified Human”
By the end of 2026, the EU Digital Identity Wallet will become the standard for European users. Expect major platforms like Steam and Patreon to eventually integrate these “Zero-Knowledge” systems.
Spicy Prediction: Instead of uploading a photo of your ID to a sketchy website, you will simply “tap” a government-authorized app. The site will receive a “Yes/No” confirmation of your age without ever seeing your name or face.
The Great Platform Migration
As “Sin Taxes” in the U.S. climb toward 10–12% in some states and ID Scans and bans come into effect, we will likely see a “Shadow Market” emerge.
Spicy Prediction: Some indie creators may be forced to move away from centralized platforms (like Steam) toward decentralized, crypto-adjacent storefronts that operate outside the reach of state-level tax collectors. However, this will push adult gaming back into the “underground,” reversing a decade of mainstream progress.
AI Bouncers vs. The VPN Arms Race
With the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2025 ruling in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton upholding state age-gating, more platforms will turn to “Age Estimation” AI (facial scans) to avoid the friction of ID uploads.
Spicy Prediction: VPN usage will become a basic utility for the average gamer, not just the tech-savvy. However, regulators are already looking at “VPN Bans” or requiring VPN providers to enforce the same age-gating as the sites they access.
The “Taxation as Normalization” Paradox
Paradoxically, the “Sin Tax” might be the very thing that saves adult gaming from total bans.
Spicy Prediction: It is very likely that some regions or states become dependent on the millions of dollars in revenue generated by adult content taxes, they will have a financial incentive to keep these platforms legal rather than banning them outright. Taxation, in this sense, becomes a form of “sinful” protection. Some countries or states may even try to take advantage of this, just like they did with gambling, drugs and prostitution.
My final thought – The “Adults Only” tag on your favorite Adult game might soon come with a surcharge and a mandatory facial scan.
Do you like the articles? Check out my Patreon! Thank you!
